{
  "schema": "ruthven-origin-manifest/1",
  "ruthvenId": "RUTHVEN-PT-0002847",
  "title": "PAPER TRAIL #2847",
  "artist": "Miss AL Simpson",
  "year": 2026,
  "collection": "PAPER TRAIL",
  "collectionSize": 4000,
  "collectionNumber": 2847,
  "edition": "1/1",
  "createdAt": "2026-09-30T18:59:45Z",
  "registeredAt": "2026-10-01T16:50:06.912Z",
  "originRecordedAt": "2026-09-30T18:59:45Z",
  "finalArtwork": {
    "kind": "FINAL_ARTWORK",
    "file": "artwork/PAPER-TRAIL-2847.png",
    "pixelSha256": "addccd5228afa065749980fabbd4e5c3c1d8752fb303e8bf3cdcd8a245e56881",
    "studioFileSha256": "093ae47dbce310d6457349dadca4f786b4af1cf587df0ea14e98255a61de3f28",
    "publicFileSha256": "eca2d6c57994dd6161f568469f765d4a915bf13f3fddad02c592f8feee44b466",
    "width": 2160,
    "height": 2160,
    "mimeType": "image/png",
    "note": "The public file is pixel-identical to the studio master; the studio file additionally carries an engine text chunk. pixelSha256 identifies the image."
  },
  "originBody": "Bitcoin Bitch",
  "summary": {
    "pieces": 13,
    "sourceWorks": 11,
    "bodies": 9,
    "archiveSpan": "2020–2026",
    "workSpecificGenerations": 2,
    "generatedFragments": 2,
    "fragmentsFromWorkSpecificGenerations": 2,
    "otherGenerationsUsed": 0,
    "archiveFragments": 11
  },
  "archiveSources": [
    {
      "sourceId": "base-0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82-1200",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "INTERFACE #1200",
      "year": 2024,
      "collection": "Interface",
      "body": "Interface",
      "chain": "base",
      "contract": "0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82",
      "tokenId": "1200",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-01.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "base-0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82-1308",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "INTERFACE #1308",
      "year": 2024,
      "collection": "Interface",
      "body": "Interface",
      "chain": "base",
      "contract": "0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82",
      "tokenId": "1308",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-02.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x277a32b16fda712d9a8c5f5a694ac7a3175f7dd7-13",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "Lola Ledger",
      "year": 2023,
      "collection": "CRYPTO PIN-UPS",
      "body": "Crypto Pin-Ups",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x277a32b16fda712d9a8c5f5a694ac7a3175f7dd7",
      "tokenId": "13",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-03.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x2b4572419f2b2a0c198cc8789de881287c09d8c3-72",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "CHANEL BUBBLES - NO 1",
      "year": 2020,
      "collection": "MISS AL SIMPSON",
      "body": "MISS AL SIMPSON",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x2b4572419f2b2a0c198cc8789de881287c09d8c3",
      "tokenId": "72",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-04.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3-165",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "THE ALGORITHMIC MUSE 165",
      "year": 2024,
      "collection": "THE ALGORITHMIC MUSE",
      "body": "The Algorithmic Muse",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3",
      "tokenId": "165",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-05.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3-183",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "THE ALGORITHMIC MUSE 183",
      "year": 2024,
      "collection": "THE ALGORITHMIC MUSE",
      "body": "The Algorithmic Muse",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3",
      "tokenId": "183",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-06.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x623509f8b87efba5ae75ab3df92b447b72ecd9b0-1",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "WAY OUT",
      "year": 2025,
      "collection": "GLITCH ANALOGUE",
      "body": "Singles & small editions",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x623509f8b87efba5ae75ab3df92b447b72ecd9b0",
      "tokenId": "1",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-07.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0x92a75e5e8ab62367fd30a5018dd4e0e087232a69-7",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "IF LOVE IS THE PREY, MERCY WITHOUT TIME",
      "year": 2025,
      "collection": "The Drones of Suburbia (Roma) - Ink Interventions",
      "body": "The Drones of Suburbia",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0x92a75e5e8ab62367fd30a5018dd4e0e087232a69",
      "tokenId": "7",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-08.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0xb932a70a57673d89f4acffbe830e8ed7f75fb9e0-50984",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "BITCOIN BITCH - ALL TIME HIGH",
      "year": 2025,
      "collection": "SuperRare",
      "body": "Bitcoin Bitch",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0xb932a70a57673d89f4acffbe830e8ed7f75fb9e0",
      "tokenId": "50984",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-09.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0xd9e7a8b15480ab2b3343e84608082d99da552de6-517",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "Gracely Right",
      "year": 2023,
      "collection": "Soulbrds",
      "body": "Soulbrds",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0xd9e7a8b15480ab2b3343e84608082d99da552de6",
      "tokenId": "517",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-10.jpg"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "ethereum-0xe7c62655148b86f8829608378c638a03e73342ba-52",
      "kind": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE",
      "title": "Blue Manga Reflections — Manga",
      "year": 2026,
      "collection": "THE MANGA MACHINE - PORCELAIN ANDROIDS",
      "body": "Porcelain Androids",
      "chain": "ethereum",
      "contract": "0xe7c62655148b86f8829608378c638a03e73342ba",
      "tokenId": "52",
      "status": "on-chain work of the artist; the file it was cut from is the studio's retrieved representation",
      "presentationFile": "ancestry/source-11.jpg"
    }
  ],
  "generations": [
    {
      "generationId": "gen-eb61313b0a4ee848",
      "role": "figure",
      "kind": "WORK_SPECIFIC_GENERATION",
      "label": "Ink Interventions 26 figure",
      "imageSha256": "eb61313b0a4ee84814d05e0b0d7acc3ee5a2433be3193d731be0c31ec1d70e1d",
      "generatedAt": "2026-09-23T16:48:42Z"
    },
    {
      "generationId": "gen-f745f64fae3d93fa",
      "role": "collage ground and pieces",
      "kind": "WORK_SPECIFIC_GENERATION",
      "label": "COLLAGE 2026 sheet",
      "imageSha256": "f745f64fae3d93fa906facdde40625225262f0eec366d1181a117c90363e35cf",
      "generatedAt": "2026-09-09T19:56:21Z"
    }
  ],
  "fragments": [
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-fe563878829616de",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "fe563878829616de8ff0df8d34c6f64b65b01dbec47b452f23500a8498e9407f",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0xb932a70a57673d89f4acffbe830e8ed7f75fb9e0-50984"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        671,
        707,
        350,
        420
      ],
      "file": "fragments/01.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-da169dc804775e76",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "da169dc804775e76988332089e7ed733cc9fde5cdba19dfb740fe7ea5fadfff4",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x92a75e5e8ab62367fd30a5018dd4e0e087232a69-7"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        146,
        828,
        137,
        105
      ],
      "file": "fragments/02.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-dc5847afcedfd2bd",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "dc5847afcedfd2bd6103aa0ccb7b4a712b590e78d90723a916632f475fbca076",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x277a32b16fda712d9a8c5f5a694ac7a3175f7dd7-13"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        509,
        481,
        1574,
        1124
      ],
      "file": "fragments/03.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-50573aa6279eeb9f",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "50573aa6279eeb9fbb6fc8face7ca7ab930a9af98b28fdaa69950348a3284492",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3-183"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        521,
        3490,
        636,
        509
      ],
      "file": "fragments/04.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-d37e4fb6521be313",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "d37e4fb6521be313cda4447903b99d907eaf2bcc594b60d811bbda2a7746aa2a",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x2b4572419f2b2a0c198cc8789de881287c09d8c3-72"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        1140,
        654,
        2592,
        2099
      ],
      "file": "fragments/05.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-ab807c512799aa3f",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "ab807c512799aa3fd59c6557f93e6ba89ae32f2a5d9f05b83e46f9f4585f6bbd",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0xe7c62655148b86f8829608378c638a03e73342ba-52"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        1779,
        743,
        420,
        361
      ],
      "file": "fragments/06.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-a23d02892c63d3a0",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "a23d02892c63d3a0d44c34422a24e021f60bba91f51f33a8a6d783a960c8e9d5",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x623509f8b87efba5ae75ab3df92b447b72ecd9b0-1"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        322,
        321,
        397,
        441
      ],
      "file": "fragments/07.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-a4b3455438d09d08",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "a4b3455438d09d08c5bc2a78aa234cb3b4037958a7ef2d295dad70ddc85d08f8",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "WORK_SPECIFIC_GENERATION",
        "sourceId": "gen-f745f64fae3d93fa"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        443,
        215,
        242,
        254
      ],
      "file": "fragments/08.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-a39ac7b26bfd1480",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "a39ac7b26bfd1480c31f3a0506ede08ec2ce98376d62df2da47364990b821760",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0x49f8108c9dca8eb0680a4e0404104dc8cb7aa6f3-165"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        1789,
        228,
        2004,
        2367
      ],
      "file": "fragments/09.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-eccff706daf2306b",
      "type": "landscape",
      "cut": "landscape-band",
      "sha256": "eccff706daf2306bdcbe1750659c7d0bffdaa451ef7d8058befdf298b807c4fb",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "base-0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82-1308"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        0,
        32,
        700,
        350
      ],
      "file": "fragments/10.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-fdf0af6e114bc6aa",
      "type": "figure",
      "cut": "cut-out",
      "sha256": "fdf0af6e114bc6aa3fea39a4a6e7ffa18de793abfb57eb0da999e20aed5b11a0",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "WORK_SPECIFIC_GENERATION",
        "sourceId": "gen-eb61313b0a4ee848"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        327,
        98,
        469,
        1365
      ],
      "file": "fragments/11.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-ab45620ee056e514",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "torn piece",
      "sha256": "ab45620ee056e51439ee3c702140f1ac0bddca5bdf15ffcaa597660dad0bb2cb",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "base-0x65a078abf1fdbf05ae5e0b56d517206e9b163b82-1200"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        290,
        558,
        207,
        208
      ],
      "file": "fragments/12.jpg"
    },
    {
      "kind": "COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT",
      "fragmentId": "frag-a4ce8241f60ec513",
      "type": "texture",
      "cut": "tile",
      "sha256": "a4ce8241f60ec51319bdb1ec0f04e2e8e2903e6ef4c1845bcd4396b00b426ca4",
      "derivedFrom": {
        "kind": "ARCHIVE_ARTWORK",
        "sourceId": "ethereum-0xd9e7a8b15480ab2b3343e84608082d99da552de6-517"
      },
      "cropOfSource": [
        205,
        1977,
        770,
        950
      ],
      "file": "fragments/13.jpg"
    }
  ],
  "placements": [
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 1,
      "fragmentId": "frag-fe563878829616de",
      "slot": "wall",
      "label": "wall",
      "box": [
        0.7218,
        0.6782,
        0.3315,
        0.3977
      ],
      "rotation": -0.95,
      "opacity": 0.88,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 2,
      "fragmentId": "frag-da169dc804775e76",
      "slot": "wall",
      "label": "wall",
      "box": [
        0.0028,
        0.6481,
        0.3417,
        0.262
      ],
      "rotation": 7.52,
      "opacity": 0.852,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 3,
      "fragmentId": "frag-dc5847afcedfd2bd",
      "slot": "wall-cross",
      "label": "wall-cross",
      "box": [
        0.3889,
        0.7046,
        0.319,
        0.2278
      ],
      "rotation": -5.61,
      "opacity": 0.946,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 4,
      "fragmentId": "frag-50573aa6279eeb9f",
      "slot": "wall-cross",
      "label": "wall-cross",
      "box": [
        -0.0218,
        0.3093,
        0.3069,
        0.2454
      ],
      "rotation": 8.73,
      "opacity": 0.965,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 5,
      "fragmentId": "frag-d37e4fb6521be313",
      "slot": "wall-cross",
      "label": "wall-cross",
      "box": [
        0.2759,
        -0.0338,
        0.4097,
        0.4079
      ],
      "rotation": -3.22,
      "opacity": 0.989,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 6,
      "fragmentId": "frag-ab807c512799aa3f",
      "slot": "wall-cross",
      "label": "wall-cross",
      "box": [
        0.2954,
        0.3458,
        0.3227,
        0.2773
      ],
      "rotation": 8.64,
      "opacity": 0.875,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 7,
      "fragmentId": "frag-a23d02892c63d3a0",
      "slot": "wall-cross",
      "label": "wall-cross",
      "box": [
        0.5736,
        0.3361,
        0.3625,
        0.4028
      ],
      "rotation": -7.43,
      "opacity": 0.92,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 8,
      "fragmentId": "frag-a4b3455438d09d08",
      "slot": "collage-pieces",
      "label": "collage piece",
      "box": [
        0.1472,
        0.5931,
        0.4773,
        0.5009
      ],
      "rotation": 15.92,
      "opacity": 0.955,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 9,
      "fragmentId": "frag-a39ac7b26bfd1480",
      "slot": "material",
      "label": "studio scan",
      "box": [
        0.3259,
        0.0884,
        0.3875,
        0.4579
      ],
      "rotation": 0.1,
      "opacity": 0.679,
      "blend": "multiply",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 10,
      "fragmentId": "frag-eccff706daf2306b",
      "slot": "landscape",
      "label": "landscape",
      "box": [
        0.0926,
        0.6259,
        0.7319,
        0.3324
      ],
      "rotation": 2.74,
      "opacity": 0.993,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 11,
      "fragmentId": "frag-fdf0af6e114bc6aa",
      "slot": "subject",
      "label": "the figure",
      "box": [
        0.312,
        -0.0366,
        0.3653,
        1.0634
      ],
      "rotation": -0.45,
      "opacity": 1,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 12,
      "fragmentId": "frag-ab45620ee056e514",
      "slot": "counter",
      "label": "counter-source",
      "box": [
        0.1931,
        0.6931,
        0.3769,
        0.3787
      ],
      "rotation": 4.38,
      "opacity": 0.896,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    },
    {
      "kind": "PLACEMENT_EVENT",
      "order": 13,
      "fragmentId": "frag-a4ce8241f60ec513",
      "slot": "sliver",
      "label": "Soulbrds sliver",
      "box": [
        -0.031,
        0.8167,
        0.0667,
        0.0824
      ],
      "rotation": 13.35,
      "opacity": 0.963,
      "blend": "normal",
      "covers": false
    }
  ],
  "graph": "ARCHIVE_SOURCE → COMPOSITION_FRAGMENT → PLACEMENT_EVENT → FINAL_ARTWORK",
  "engine": {
    "name": "Miss AL Simpson Archive Engine",
    "version": "0.1.0",
    "grammar": "1.12",
    "recipeSha256": "34fe502a140d7a669503ebe80d63c6413f68f2e594fece3024b9bafc72c5acec"
  },
  "artworkCharacteristics": [
    {
      "trait_type": "Composition",
      "value": "Typographic Wall"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Lead source",
      "value": "INTERFACE #1308, 2024"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Sliver",
      "value": "Gracely Right"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Origin body",
      "value": "Bitcoin Bitch"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Counter-source",
      "value": "Interface"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Density",
      "value": "Full"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Background Colour",
      "value": "JPG Black"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Sheet",
      "value": "Bare ground"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Material",
      "value": "Studio original"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Layers",
      "value": "13"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Edge",
      "value": "Contained"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Sources",
      "value": "11"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Bodies",
      "value": "9"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Drawn from",
      "value": "The Algorithmic Muse, Bitcoin Bitch, Crypto Pin-Ups, The Drones of Suburbia, Interface, MISS AL SIMPSON, Porcelain Androids, Singles & small editions, Soulbrds"
    },
    {
      "trait_type": "Format",
      "value": "2160×2160"
    }
  ],
  "copyrightHolder": "MISS AL SIMPSON LIMITED",
  "verificationStatus": "CRYPTOGRAPHICALLY_ANCHORED",
  "passport": {
    "file": "passport/RUTHVEN-PT-0002847.html",
    "note": "The page as issued for a public reader at build time; its file hash is in package-manifest.json. Re-issued Passports carry the root CID once pinned."
  },
  "tokenisation": {
    "status": "NOT_TOKENISED",
    "note": "A token, when minted, is attached to this RUTHVEN record. It does not replace the identity."
  },
  "publicProvenance": {
    "protocol": "ipfs",
    "rootCid": null,
    "note": "The root CID is assigned by pinning and recorded in the RUTHVEN ledger; this file predates it by design."
  }
}